Hard News by Russell Brown

Read Post

Hard News: The War Stories

32 Responses

First ←Older Page 1 2 Newer→ Last

  • Richard Aston,

    And on Jim Mora's radio show this avo . Shirley Murray a NZ hymn writer on her Anzac hymn . The controversial third verse is being omitted by many.

    Honour the brave whose conscience was their call,
    answered no bugle, went against the wall,
    suffered in prisons of contempt and shame,
    branded as cowards, in our country's name.

    The conscientious objectors , like James K's father Archibald Baxter who were seen as cowards .

    Not a cool thing to note I know, in the midst of honoring the brave, but when I look at damage that 6 years of being a solder did to my father. I cannot help but reflect on the inhuman result of war.

    Not all wars were noble ones .

    And yes those poor bastards who went to fight for ideals and to protect those at home , they too have my deep respect and my grieving.

    Northland • Since Nov 2006 • 510 posts Report Reply

  • Ken Sparks,

    Anzac Day just makes me sad and I've never felt moved to join a dawn parade and stand around with people who generally think war is either honourable or at least unavoidable. Call me an idealist but I'm with the conscientious objectors. Didn't stop me from taking my son to see 'Lawrence of Arabia' in glorious 4K last Sunday though...

    Cox’s Creek • Since Apr 2011 • 60 posts Report Reply

  • Henare,

    I have taken my son since he inherited his Koro's medals. It's nothing to do with glorifying war, it's about honouring the effort and loss made by a couple of generations.

    Wellington • Since Nov 2011 • 5 posts Report Reply

  • Ana Simkiss,

    The particular devastation of the world wars on Maori can't be underestimated. I don't know, but would not be surprised to learn, that they are a high proportion of the armed forces today.

    Freemans Bay • Since Nov 2006 • 141 posts Report Reply

  • ChrisW,

    Attachment Attachment Attachment

    My preparation today for Anzac Day involved visiting the Gisborne district war memorial cenotaph to photograph it complete with its marble soldier on top. The monument was damaged in the December 2007 earthquake. Subsequent investigations indicate it is in poor structural condition on weak foundations close to the riverbank. The soldier is to be removed immediately after Anzac Day for safe-keeping, associated with a decision to restore and rebuild the monument more robustly at major expense.

    “The Sorrow and the Pride” expressed in marble and bronze in the early 1920s – the dislocation of the column not to be ignored.

    No hint of glory in this soldier. The pohutukawa leaves turn up in a fresh breeze to complement the marble.

    That marble soldier seems thoroughly expressive. I’ve never seen this with clarity before, so high out of reach of the naked eye view – unfortunately so.

    Gisborne • Since Apr 2009 • 851 posts Report Reply

  • Hebe, in reply to ChrisW,

    That marble soldier seems thoroughly expressive.

    And young, so young,

    Christchurch • Since May 2011 • 2899 posts Report Reply

  • Chris Waugh, in reply to Hebe,

    And young, so young,

    I've been doing my usual Anzac Day lesson this week. It's a certain kind of magic to tell my students that those soldiers were their own age when they lost their lives and see - physically see the expressions on their faces and the lights in their eyes - that little statement sink in.

    Speaking of... ChrisW, either that is a 19 year old veteran pretending to be marble, or the sculptor was a magician of the highest order. Particularly in your close-up of his face, I see life, love, relief, mourning, pride, regret, and all to a degree that one should not be able to see in a child so young. I must get back to Gisborne one of these days; remind me to look up that statue and pay my respects when I do.

    Wellington • Since Jan 2007 • 2401 posts Report Reply

  • Ken Sparks,

    Really good to see Kay and Annie's doco just now - always a pleasure seeing Jake Bryant's camerawork too. I have huge respect for Jon Stephenson and it was fascinating seeing him at work in the field. Maybe our army should only be used for national emergencies and actual overseas aid and reconstruction projects - a truly pacifist force...

    Cox’s Creek • Since Apr 2011 • 60 posts Report Reply

  • Russell Brown, in reply to Ana Simkiss,

    The particular devastation of the world wars on Maori can’t be underestimated. I don’t know, but would not be surprised to learn, that they are a high proportion of the armed forces today.

    Yes, that's absolutely the case.

    Auckland • Since Nov 2006 • 22850 posts Report Reply

  • ChrisW, in reply to Chris Waugh,

    I must get back to Gisborne one of these days; remind me to look up that statue and pay my respects when I do.

    Please do - but he won't be back for a year or two yet. I suspect the centenary of Anzac Day itself in 2015 will be a more realistic schedule than next year.

    Gisborne • Since Apr 2009 • 851 posts Report Reply

  • ChrisW,

    Attachment Attachment

    Compared with that marble soldier, the Te Aroha WWI memorial in bronze, grey granite and cast iron takes a very different stance! The aggression seems dissonant with the inscription “Lord into thy hands we commend their spirits”.

    No sign of prideful sorrow here.

    Could it have been a “boy named Sue” effect relating to a town named “The Love”? Nevertheless it’s real cultural history in itself and looks remarkable against the bush slopes of Te Aroha mountain. Another photo of its town context in the record store/music thread.

    Gisborne • Since Apr 2009 • 851 posts Report Reply

  • linger, in reply to ChrisW,

    The aggression seems dissonant with the inscription “Lord into thy hands we commend their spirits”.

    … indeed: presumably the inscription is supposed to refer to the list of the fallen, but really the only way of reconciling the verbal and visual messages is to read “their” as referring to “those we killed” (cf. Patton’s comment that war “isn’t about dying for your country, it’s about making the other poor bastard die for theirs”). And, well, yeah, we should remember also that there are other fallen than our own.

    Tokyo • Since Apr 2007 • 1944 posts Report Reply

  • BenWilson, in reply to Ana Simkiss,

    The particular devastation of the world wars on Maori can't be underestimated. I don't know, but would not be surprised to learn, that they are a high proportion of the armed forces today.

    They are. Somewhere around 20%. Interestingly, Maori women are even more represented, as a proportion of the female armed forces, over 25%. The overall proportion of women is still quite low, though, less than 20% of the army are women.

    Just a pedantic thing here, but it's better to say they "shouldn't be underestimated" rather than that they "can't be underestimated". The latter phrasing implies they are zero.

    Auckland • Since Nov 2006 • 10657 posts Report Reply

  • Russell Brown,

    This is good news: He Toki Huna: New Zealand In Afghanistan is available for viewing on-demand.

    Auckland • Since Nov 2006 • 22850 posts Report Reply

  • Robert Urquhart,

    Christchurch • Since Mar 2009 • 163 posts Report Reply

  • Tamsin6,

    And we don't just remember the soldiers. My great-great aunt Marion Brown, of Southland, died when the Marquette was torpedoed.
    http://muse.aucklandmuseum.com/databases/Cenotaph/1781.detail

    A little more detail here:
    http://www.rootsweb.ancestry.com/~nzlscant/marquette.htm

    London • Since Dec 2007 • 133 posts Report Reply

  • Graeme Edgeler, in reply to BenWilson,

    They are. Somewhere around 20%.

    At the 2006 census, the proportion of people aged 20-29 who gave a clear answer to the Maori descent question and who indicated they were of Maori descent was over 20%.

    Wellington, New Zealand • Since Nov 2006 • 3215 posts Report Reply

  • Graeme Edgeler, in reply to Richard Aston,

    The conscientious objectors , like James K’s father Archibald Baxter who were seen as cowards .

    This article from the VUW Student Magazine Salient had a pretty big effect on me when I first read it.

    Wellington, New Zealand • Since Nov 2006 • 3215 posts Report Reply

  • BenWilson, in reply to Graeme Edgeler,

    The mean age for army personnel at that time was around 29.5 according to this study. So I think comparing to the general population, rather than just the 20-29 year old population, is relevant. Although that is quite an interesting stat.

    Auckland • Since Nov 2006 • 10657 posts Report Reply

  • Henare,

    Attachment

    This is in Cambridge. Nothing glorious about this ANZAC. Yet it probably refelcted more accurately the feeling of the families left behind.

    Wellington • Since Nov 2011 • 5 posts Report Reply

  • Islander, in reply to Henare,

    And the blokes who fought in the desert campaigns-

    one of the utterly inglorious things about the WW1 campaign is what happened to the horses.
    My blown-to-bits greatuncle Peter took his horse to war. Neither of them came back.
    Bad enough BUT
    -there was - I understand - a deliberate decision, made on financial grounds, not to repatriate ANZ horses-
    hate pollies?
    O Yes! I do!

    Big O, Mahitahi, Te Wahi … • Since Feb 2007 • 5643 posts Report Reply

  • Henare,

    According to this story Bess came back.

    Wellington • Since Nov 2011 • 5 posts Report Reply

  • Islander, in reply to Henare,

    Yes, indeedy.
    Out of the 10,000 plus who went overseas, only (only!) half of which were estimated
    to have been killed on battlefields.
    Peter's horse is still remembered in the whanau (as well as Peter of course!) because he was unusually intelligent & well-trained.

    Big O, Mahitahi, Te Wahi … • Since Feb 2007 • 5643 posts Report Reply

  • Ross Mason,

    My Gallipoli bound Granddad, just before he left Middle East, along with practically the whole Canterbury Mounteds, took their horses down to the beach and shot them. He said it was because they would not leave them for the locals as they treated theirs appallingly. They couldn't bear seeing theirs treated the same way.

    He managed to get back with a bullet grooved skull and a piece of metal inserted to cover the wound.

    Upper Hutt • Since Jun 2007 • 1590 posts Report Reply

  • Kyle Matthews, in reply to Islander,

    -there was - I understand - a deliberate decision, made on financial grounds, not to repatriate ANZ horses-

    Also quarantine reasons. According to wikipedia, 136,000 horses were shipped from Australia. 13,000 were left at the end of the war, only one returned to Australia, the rest were killed or went to India.

    Since Nov 2006 • 6243 posts Report Reply

First ←Older Page 1 2 Newer→ Last

Post your response…

Please sign in using your Public Address credentials…

Login

You may also create an account or retrieve your password.